Bartomeu comes clean but do the figures add up?

Bartomeu 2014Josep Maria Bartomeu faced the press for just over two hours this evening and took questions for the first time as Barça’s new president. Bartomeu confirmed he will complete the mandate won by Sandro Rosell’s team in the 2010 elections and that he has the intention of presenting the same team at the next elections in 2016 with the intention of serving another six-year term.

Bartomeu gave a very competent performance in answering questions on a number of subjects ranging from regrets over saying Eric Abidal’s contract would be renewed if he played again (a misunderstanding as he meant to say the contract which was in suspension would be reactivated)  or whether he intends to call Johan Cruyff (yes) to his arguments to revalidate his presidency given the members voted for Rosell to which he responded by mentioning the club statutes and that he formed part of Rosell’s candidacy.

Obviously most interest was centred on the controversial Neymar transfer and Bartomeu tried to stay one step ahead by bringing up the subject in his initial statement and then by bringing out Raul Sanllehi, who was the chief negotiator in the Neymar deal, to present the figures step-by-step. Bartomeu claimed that the club hadn’t previously been able to reveal all the details because of confidentiality clauses, but that Neymar’s father, having seen all the kerfuffle being caused this week, decided to call Barça and lift the clauses.

Sanllehi presented the figures with a screen which unfortunately didn’t help because it appeared to be hurriedly prepared. The numbers were presented, first the €40 million to Neymar’s parents’ company N&N, this payment was due to the clause in the 2011 precontract which Barça felt it necessary to pay to prevent another club (read Real Madrid here, though Bartomeu said many big clubs were interested) from paying the other clause of €40 million to Barça in order to poach the player.

Next was the €17.1 million paid to Santos as a fee for their part of Neymar’s rights. So far so good as we now reach the €57.1 million that Barça continue to insist was the total price for the transfer. Sanllehi then went on to talk of other payments and concepts, a €2 million bonus if Neymar becomes a Ballon d’Or finalist, €4 million for marketing, €2 million to Neymar’s father’s scouting firm, a 5% payment to an agent and two friendly games which he claimed were ‘free’. It all became a bit confusing. While the €7.9 million paid to Santos for the option on three young players may be seen to be separate from the Neymar deal and the €2.5 million dedicated to social works in Brazil’s favelas can be accepted simply because it is a good thing to do, it is difficult to accept that a friendly is free when it seems Santos will earn €4.5 million from each game, and the €2 million for the scouting company could easily be a cover for an extra payment. Bizarrely, Sanllehi finished by adding up his own figures, arriving at a figure of €86.2 million plus the €2 million Ballon d’Or bonus and then clarifying by saying the figure was meaningless as the total amount paid for the Neymar transfer was €57.1 million. It was all too confusing for some, one journalist complained that he had tried adding up the figures several time and that he kept arriving at €73.5 million.

Taking questions from the press Bartomeu admitted that he could also be included in the judge’s investigation into the case but he insisted he had no intention of resigning even if he were eventually charged as he has done nothing wrong. In this sense he remained strong as he did in his backing for his ‘friend’ Rosell. He reinforced the importance in Rosell’s decision of the death threats against his family, however, later when asked if he thought Rosell had been happy in the job, the new president let slip that he’d seen a happy Rosell ‘until a couple of days ago’ which only succeeded in demonstrating the dominating reason for Rosell’s resignation to be Judge Ruz’s decision on Wednesday to investigate the case. The insistence that Barça have done nothing wrong combined with Rosell’s sudden change of heart this week makes a difficult equation. Bartomeu put on a good show of being a man in control of the situation and his willingness to answer all questions directly was creditable. We will now have to see if Jordi Cases continues or not with the case. It seems very clear that Cases is acting as a Barcelonista with his best intentions for the well-being of the club. Many feel he may let the matter lie now as he had no intention of causing a crisis within the club. We should know one way or the other next week.

This entry was posted in Josep Maria Bartomeu, Neymar, Opinion, Sandro Rosell and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Bartomeu comes clean but do the figures add up?

  1. Pingback: Bartomeu comes clean but do the figures add up? | FC Barcelona 4 Ever

  2. Wow….just still unbelievable to me. The institution is obviously in crisis. However, to me, Neymar is worth more than Gareth Bale, comparing oranges to apples obviously but even at 80M I am all for it. I dont think anyone could sign Messi from Barcelona for less than 150M, ever. That puts things in perspective a bit for me when valuing the soundness of the business decision in this transfer. Is Neymar worth half of what Messi would be in this marjet?empathic YES from me. What I do not like about all this is that they have lost all legitimacy with rossell’s resignation and, as Johan C says, they should revalidate the mandate. I just hope that all teams (futbol, bcesto, hokey, alustar, feminino, cantera, etc.) react as they a always have when faced with a shock to the system:win on the field and punto. They are dancing around our “institutional cadaver” in Madrid but our resurrection starts against Malaga and will not stop until we bring another CL home. I am putting REAL money on that CL win this year just because…

    • barcacentralnic says:

      It seems clear that Barça got pulled into paying more for the player because of bids from other clubs, and almost certainly in particular a bid from Real Madrid. In many ways I can understand Rosell not wanting to admit to paying more – at the time I was not alone in thinking €57 million was too much – and there may be some defence for Rosell on account of him simply respecting a confidentiality clause. However, he is a victim of his own rhetoric and his promises of transparency as well as his paranoia which led to his evasiveness with the press.
      It’s ironic that I predicted that Rosell could be judged on the Neymar signing. I was worried the player might flop and I’m happy to admit I was wrong in this respect. In the end Rosell proved he made a good choice with the player and as Bartomeu said ‘the player wouldn’t be here if it wasn’t for Rosell’. but the deal still proved to be the cause of his downfall.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s