Luis Suarez or Alexis Sanchez

Luis Suarez bite world cup 2014The news that Barça are negotiating with Liverpool for the transfer of Luis Suarez worries me deeply. Don’t get me wrong, Suarez is a fantastic player who is capable of causing problems to the best of defences, and I’m not about to get all moralistic about his bizarre behaviour on the pitch, but more on that later. The main reason for my concern is it seems that we are going to sell Alexis Sanchez to make way for the Uruguayan while the figures being mentioned for the possible transfer fees make as little sense as when we swapped Samuel Eto’o + €43 million to sign Zlatan Ibrahimovic.

Alexis 2014Alexis has had his best season at Barça and has now just performed admirably for Chile at the World Cup. He may have had problems with his finishing in the past but this side of his game has improved significantly, he works hard for the team and accepts his role and he seems to want to stay. Barça should really be offering him an improved contract, at 25 he is two years younger than Suarez, and it would seem a pretty safe bet that we could get at least three or four good years from the Chilean. Instead we seem prepared to sell him (possibly to Arsenal) for around €40 million which might not seem such a bad price unless you compare it to the €36 million paid by Manchester United for Ander Herrera or PSG paying €50 million for David Luiz.

Who is responsible for this madness? Zubi? Bartomeu? Luis Enrique? According to some sources Luis Enrique has told Alexis he is happy if he stays but the club have already succeeded in making Alexis feel unwanted. Liverpool’s asking price of €88 million for Suarez is way more than we should be thinking of paying if we do go through with the deal. The Uruguayan’s quality is not in doubt and he would bring some valuable aggression to the attack that we haven’t seen at Camp Nou since the days of Hristo Stoichkov. However, at 27 Suarez may not have so long left at the top while he may also need time to adapt. Given that he is banned from playing until the end of October his adaptation could prove more difficult and then how many good years will we get when he does find his place in Barça’s Messi-based formation?

And what of the biting and the other unsavoury behaviour such as the “racist” incident with Patrice Evra? Well, first I don’t believe Suarez is some Hitler-loving card-carrying  nazi, probably more just a knobhead who in a Mourinho-like way looks to use all means necessary to gain an advantage over his opponent but fails to realise when he has crossed the line. I do not expect that Barça’s players should be angels. Stoichkov certainly wasn’t, yet he was the most exciting and arguably the most important player of Johan Cruyff’s Dream Team and he was greatly loved by Camp Nou. Suarez may have the excuse for his behaviour in a difficult family background combined with the fact that he grew up playing street football in Montevideo. While his bite on Chiellini was outrageous I think I was more horrified by an apparently-educated man such as Bartomeu saying it was honorable of Suarez to apologize for the deed, when it seems pretty obvious to everybody that he only apologised (six days later) due to pressure from Barça for him to do so. This seems to me the equivalent of a mother dragging her naughty kid round to the neighbours’ house to get him to apologise for killing their pet and then telling everybody else what a good boy little Johnny is for knowing how to say sorry! Sometimes these twisted attempts to defend the mes que un club image can get a bit nauseating. Who do they think they are kidding?

When all is said and done Suarez would come with baggage and despite his talent he may turn out to be a liability if he gets any more lengthy bans or gets himself sent off in an important game. Personally, I’d say a fair market price for him would be around €60 million while I’d say Alexis should be valued at a minimum of €50 million. However, I should insist that even if these were the agreed prices I would still not be in favour of bringing in Suarez at the expense of Alexis. Yet it seems we may end up paying more for Suarez and getting less for Alexis when we all know we need the money for signings in other positions. As with Neymar’s signing last season there again seems to be a lack of direction in the squad formation with more importance given to bringing in big names than to building a winning team. Bartomeu has promised that other signings are in the bag but that they will be revealed after the World Cup. I wait eagerly for the news of a quality central defender.  

This entry was posted in Alexis Sanchez, Josep Maria Bartomeu, Luis Enrique, Luis Suarez, New signings, Opinion, Transfers, Uncategorized, Zubizarreta and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to Luis Suarez or Alexis Sanchez

  1. Angel Gómez says:

    I agree with you. We have a surplus of attack and we´ll be adding Deulofeu. The priority is, as has been for the last 3 years, a top level central, not an attacker. I suspect FIFA will somehow diminish Suarez´s ban but the deal makes no sense to me. Kind regards from Venezuela

  2. Elwin says:

    Don’t forget Suarez missed the first 6 games last season to end up being the premierships top scorer. I wander what Nehmar will make of it all? Anyway, why would Liverpool get another striker, we’ve already got Sturridge and Lambert, we need centrebacks too!!

  3. layibiyi says:

    I be chilling still. With leaders like this, nothing can surprise me.

  4. barcacentralomer says:

    Something tells me that the Board want to squander the entire transfer budget on this ridiculous transfer and then expect Alves and Alba to be converted into CBs.

  5. Fredegar says:

    Still, if it clicks (and there’s absolutley no guarantee of course that it will), a trio of Neymar-Messi-Suarez would frighten any team in Europe. Plus, while I like Alexis and recognise that he had a far better third season with us, our attack never really worked with him in it, so a change seems like a good idea…
    The game last night also showed we have a big choice to make concerning Mascherano. He clearly proved he is one of the best defensive midfielders in the world, but that’s a place he can’t occupy in our team, so what do we do with him? Continue to misuse him as a CB or sell him?

    • Caleb says:

      I see your point, Fredegar, but is this really the right time to run an experiment in attack that will cost us tens of millions of Euros when we have huge personnel issues in defense? I could understand trading our second leading scorer for another player if it was one of the only areas needing improvement, but it seems like the money really would be better spent on some of the less exciting but ultimately essential positions.

      I think Masch should potentially play ahead of Busi. Busi’s passing may be better, but not by much—seriously, Masch had some amazing passes yesterday. Masch is certainly better on the defensive side of things. He shut down the Netherlands yesterday, and was so good at organizing the team. When he drops in between the CBs, it’s a much safer tactical move than if Busi does the same, because Masch actually has the skills and speed to play as a CB. Remember Pato blowing by Busi as if Busquets were just walking?

      It is wrong to go into the season just expecting that those who started last season should start this season, and Busi needs to earn his spot every game. (Masch deserves consideration to be captain, too (IMHO)).

    • Caleb says:

      Also, now we’ll have a front line of three players that will not press with anything resembling intensity. There will be even more pressure on the defense.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s